All attacks on John McCain

Attacker:

 

Truth-O-Meter says:

Obama

Barack Obama

"And 100 percent, John, of your ads . . . 100 percent of them have been negative."

 

Pants on fire!

No, McCain's ads haven't all been negative

Obama

Barack Obama

"Senator McCain would pay for part of his (health care) plan by making drastic cuts in Medicare — $882-billion worth."

False

Obama knows McCain's intentions better than McCain?

Obama

Barack Obama

"In April, Sen. McCain came out against helping women earn equal pay for equal work."

Mostly true

McCain opposed law for equal pay lawsuits

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain called for less regulation 21 times just this year.

Mostly true

21 bottles of deregulation on the wall

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain is "selectively editing Joe Biden's words...Biden actually said about Barack Obama: 'They're gonna find out this guy's got steel in his spine.'"

Barely True

Campaigns volley over Biden's warning

Planned Parenthood

Planned Parenthood

John McCain's health care plan "won't guarantee coverage of cancer screenings or maternity care."

True

Few "guarantees" in McCain's plan

Biden

Joe Biden

"One percent of the American people make over 21 percent of all the income in America. That wasn’t the way before George Bush became president."

Half-True

The rich are, in fact, getting richer

Obama

Barack Obama

"The centerpiece of Senator McCain's education policy is to increase the voucher program in D.C. by 2,000 slots."

False

Centerpiece? More like a side dish

Obama

Barack Obama

Under John McCain's health care plan, people get a $5,000 tax credit to buy a $12,000 health care policy, and "that's a loss for you."

False

A major distortion on McCain's policy

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain "is proposing tax cuts that would give the average Fortune 500 CEO an additional $700,000 in tax cuts."

Mostly true

High earners get a break under McCain's plan

Biden

Joe Biden

"John McCain voted against funding the troops because of . . . a timeline in it to draw down American troops."

True

McCain opposed 2007 war funding bill

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain intervened on behalf of Charles Keating with federal regulators... that allowed Keating to continue his fraud at an incredible cost to taxpayers.

Mostly true

Obama revives an 80s scandal

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain's health care plan "leaves you on your own to pay McCain’s health insurance tax."

Barely True

Health care ad is right -- until the end

Biden

Joe Biden

"John McCain said...in December he was surprised there was a subprime mortgage problem."

Mostly true

Biden more or less right on McCain's subprime surprise

Biden

Joe Biden

Sen. McCain's tax plan provides "virtually nothing to the middle class."

Barely True

McCain's tax plan doesn't ignore middle class

Biden

Joe Biden

John McCain said "he wouldn't even sit down with the government of Spain, a NATO ally that has troops in Afghanistan with us now."

Barely True

McCain refused to commit

Planned Parenthood

Planned Parenthood

Says McCain "voted to let governments charge rape victims" for forensic exams.

Pants on fire!

Ad distorts McCain's record on Violence Against Women Act

Obama

Barack Obama

"There are so many loopholes ... our businesses pay effectively one of the lowest tax rates in the world."

Half-True

Obama oversimplifies corporate taxes

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain "has threatened extinction for North Korea and sung songs about bombing Iran."

Half-True

One Obama example is just too old

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain "said the other day that he would not meet potentially with the prime minister of Spain, because he . . . wasn't sure whether they were aligned with us."

Mostly true

Yes, wary about Spain — and maybe confused, too

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain wants to "give oil companies another $4-billion" in tax breaks.

True

Better context for a once-questionable tax claim

Obama

Barack Obama

 "I introduced a bill that would’ve helped stop the multimillion-dollar bonus packages that CEOs grab on their way out.. (McCain) opposed that idea."

Barely True

McCain never talked about the bill

Obama

Barack Obama

Obama says McCain went to Bermuda and "pledged to protect tax breaks for American corporations that hide their profits offshore."

Mostly true

Yes, McCain said he would oppose some changes

Obama

Barack Obama

"Grateful insurance company executives and their lobbyists" from Bermuda gave McCain $50,000.

True

McCain did get money from Bermuda-connected sources

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain "has opposed stem cell research."

False

Obama ad distorts McCain's stem cell position

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain would "reduce oversight of health insurance."

Half-True

Forecasting another market collapse?

Obama

Barack Obama

"But if my opponent had his way, the millions of Floridians who rely on it would've had their Social Security tied up in the stock market this week."

False

Obama overstates McCain's plan, whatever that is

Obama

Barack Obama

Obama ad contends that John McCain endorses Rush Limbaugh's comments about immigration.

Pants on fire!

Limbaugh's not a McCain spokesman

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain "voted to cut education funding, against accountability standards. He even proposed abolishing the Department of Education."

Barely True

Cherry-picking the record

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain economic adviser Phil Gramm is "the architect of some of the deregulation in Washington that helped cause the mess on Wall Street."

Half-True

Former adviser supported deregulation

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain said last year he didn't know of a solution to the mortgage crisis.

True

McCain said he had confidence in Paulson

Biden

Joe Biden

"When George Bush said we shouldn’t investigate why the government’s response to Hurricane Katrina was so incompetent, John McCain stood with him."

Half-True

McCain supported Republican-backed investigation

Obama

Barack Obama

"He admits he still doesn’t know how to use a computer, can’t send an e-mail."

Mostly true

McCain is not computer savvy

Biden

Joe Biden

John McCain's tax plan will give no reduction "for 100-million American families."

Half-True

100-million people is more accurate

Biden

Joe Biden

McCain supports tax breaks for companies that ship jobs overseas.

Barely True

It's not quite that simple

Biden

Joe Biden

McCain voted 19 times against a minimum-wage increase.

True

The Democrats counted correctly

Obama

Barack Obama

"John McCain has voted with George Bush 90 percent of the time."

True

Update. Obama nailed it

Biden

Joe Biden

Three years ago, John McCain said, "Afghanistan — we don't read about it anymore in papers because it succeeded."

True

Biden digs back on Afghanistan to dig McCain

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain "said no to higher fuel-efficiency standards for cars."

Barely True

McCain has a mixed record on fuel economy standards

Obama

Barack Obama

"Today, we import triple the amount of oil than we had on the day Senator McCain took office."

True

Indeed we do

Schweitzer

Brian Schweitzer

McCain’s energy plan is a "single-answer proposition" — new domestic oil drilling.

Pants on fire!

McCain energy plan not just more drilling

Clinton

Hillary Clinton

McCain "still thinks it’s okay when women don't earn equal pay for equal work."

False

No, he's just not okay with one bill

Biden

Joe Biden

(McCain) says "we can't have ... timelines to draw down our troops from Iraq."

Half-True

McCain has often opposed timelines, but not always

Planned Parenthood

Planned Parenthood

McCain "said he was 'stumped' when asked whether contraceptives help stop the spread of HIV."

True

This condom speaks the truth

Clinton

Hillary Clinton

"John McCain wants to privatize Social Security."

Barely True

McCain not committed to 'privatization'

Biden

Joe Biden

Says McCain once said that on "the most important issues of our day, I’ve been totally in agreement and support of President Bush."

True

That's what McCain said — in 2005

Biden

Joe Biden

Says McCain "supported George Bush's policies 95 percent of the time."

Half-True

Cherry-picking McCain's record

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain has seven houses.

Mostly true

UPDATED: Eight houses for John & Cindy McCain

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain, “voted against renewable sources of energy, against biofuels, against solar power, against wind power.... "

Mostly true

McCain has done a little for renewable energy

Obama

Barack Obama

"Sen. McCain was already turning his sights to Iraq just days after 9/11, and he became a leading supporter of an invasion and occupation of (Iraq)."

True

McCain's record on Iraq: eager to attack

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain's attacks on Obama are 'not true,' 'false,' 'baloney,' according to media outlets.

Half-True

Off on the wrong footnotes

Obama

Barack Obama

"John McCain's top foreign policy adviser lobbied for... the Republic of Georgia, and McCain has mirrored the position advocated by the government."

True

McCain's on Georgia's side (so is Obama)

The Democratic National Committee

The Democratic National Committee

McCain is "raising campaign cash with one of (Jack) Abramoff's closest business partners: scandal-plagued conservative activist Ralph Reed."

True

McCain teams up with old rival, scandals notwithstanding

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain worries about nuclear waste in Arizona, but not in Nevada.

Barely True

McCain thinks Yucca site will be more secure

Obama

Barack Obama

"McCain opposed a requirement that the government buy American-made motorcycles. And he said all buy-American provisions were quote 'disgraceful.' "

True

McCain opposed "Buy American" rules

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain offers "billions in tax breaks for oil and drug companies, but almost nothing for families like yours."

Barely True

Tax breaks for all companies; credit for kids.

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain refuses to support a new bipartisan energy bill "because it would take away tax breaks from oil companies like Exxon Mobil."

False

McCain opposes taxes but hasn't commented on bill

Obama

Barack Obama

"Big oil's filling John McCain's campaign with $2-million in contributions."

Mostly true

Make that at least $2-million

Chain e-mail

Chain e-mail

John McCain will keep the estate tax at 0 percent, the same as it is now.

False

Larger estates will be taxed, just like now

Money Watch

Campaign Money Watch

"McCain got more money from Airbus’ U.S. executives than any other politician."

True

McCain campaign bouyed by Airbus execs and lobbyists

Money Watch

Campaign Money Watch

"John McCain intervened, which helped Airbus get that Pentagon contract."

Barely True

Letters don't amount to intervening

VoteVets.org

VoteVets.org

"Sen. McCain would occupy Iraq indefinitely, against their wishes."

False

No fresh evidence of what McCain would do

Obama

Barack Obama

"Sen. McCain's economic plan gives nearly $4-billion in tax breaks to the oil companies but doesn't provide any tax relief to more than 100-million middle-class families."

Barely True

Something for the middle, more for the top

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain has switched to Obama's position on more troops to Afghanistan.

True

Ground conditions have changed, too

Obama

Barack Obama

"McCain used to buck his party on immigration by fighting for comprehensive reform. . . . But when he was running for his party's nomination, he . . . said that he wouldn't even support his own legislation if it came up for a vote."

Mostly true

Backtracking on the path to citizenship

The Democratic National Committee

The Democratic National Committee

John McCain has given erratic and inconsistent answers on when troops should return from Iraq.

Barely True

Ad takes most of McCain quotes out of context

Obama

Barack Obama

"McCain will give more tax breaks to big oil."

Barely True

Big oil, like all companies, would get tax break

Biden

Joe Biden

John McCain has changed position on invading Iraq.

Barely True

McCain doesn't flip-flop much on Iraq

Barr

Bob Barr

"The legislation ... that Senator McCain supports would provide the authority for the federal government to surveille American citizens in their own country without any suspicion whatsoever that they're engaging in discussions with terrorists or about criminal activity."

True

While on Big Brother watch, Barr hits McCain

Clark

Wesley Clark

McCain "hasn't held executive responsibility."

False

McCain ran a Navy unit of 1,000 people

Obama

Barack Obama

"When he was asked a few years ago whether he could see himself lifting the cap on the payroll tax, (McCain) said, 'I could.' But today he's attacking me for holding the very same position."

True

McCain flipped on payroll taxes, if only once

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain "opposed legislation to fund levees and flood control programs, which he considers pork."

Half-True

He didn’t brand them all “pork”

Obama

Barack Obama

"McCain lobbied for (a) $10-million pork project honoring conservative justice."

Mostly true

It sure looks like pork

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain opposed bankruptcy protections for families "who were only in bankruptcy because of medical expenses they couldn't pay."

True

No exemptions for debtors

The Democratic National Committee

The Democratic National Committee

John McCain says he never supported the privatization of Social Security, even though video shows he did.

Half-True

'Privatization' gets 'personal'

Obama

Barack Obama

"John McCain decided to stand with George Bush 95 percent of the time (last year)."

True

That's what the votes show, yes

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain "has not led on nonproliferation issues when he had the chance in the Senate."

True

Present for votes, but not a player

Obama

Barack Obama

When McCain was questioned about hiring lobbyists to his campaign staff, "his top lobbyist actually had the nerve to say, 'The American people won’t care about this.' "

True

Obama's right, McCain's campaign said it doesn't matter

Obama

Barack Obama

McCain "hired some of the biggest lobbyists in Washington to run his campaign."

True

They were hired

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

John McCain, "one of the richest people in a Senate filled with millionaires," says the solution to the housing crisis is for people to get a "second job" and "skip their vacations."

Barely True

He's rich, but that's not his housing fix

Obama

Barack Obama

"Privatizing Social Security was a bad idea when George W. Bush proposed it. It’s a bad idea today. Sen. McCain’s campaign went even further ... suggesting ... to cut cost-of-living adjustments or to raise the retirement age."

Barely True

Reading too much into McCain’s ambitions

Obama

Barack Obama

John McCain "is one of the few senators of either party who oppose this bill (to expand education aid for veterans) because he thinks it's too generous."

Barely True

McCain's opposed, but he's not alone

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

McCain "voted against a bill to ban waterboarding, and then applauded President Bush for vetoing that ban."

Half-True

Waterboarding one aspect of larger measure

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

"The pastor McCain calls his 'spiritual guide,' Rod Parsley, believes America's founding mission is to destroy Islam, which he calls a 'false religion.' "

Half-True

Parsley and McCain relationship appears political, not spiritual

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

McCain sought the political support of minister John Hagee, "who believes Hurricane Katrina was God's punishment for gay rights and called the Catholic Church 'the Antichrist' and a 'false cult.'"

True

True, but Hagee has since recanted

Barr

Bob Barr

Eliminating earmarks "would make barely a drop in the bucket with regard to the national debt, the deficit."

Mostly true

Billions of difference amounts to not much

Consumer Action Network

Florida Consumer Action Network

"For what we spend in just one week in Iraq, 800,000 children could get health insurance for an entire year."

Mostly true

That money could insure twice as many kids

Obama

Barack Obama

"If Senator Clinton or John McCain had stood up in previous years for increases in fuel efficiency standards . . . then we would not be in this same situation in the first place."

Half-True

McCain took a stand years earlier

The Democratic National Committee

The Democratic National Committee

"McCain has voted repeatedly at least six times against funding for global HIV/AIDS, malaria and TB fund, once as one of only 14 senators."

Half-True

Selectively choosing his votes

Obama

Barack Obama

"He’s promising four more years of an administration that will push for the privatization of Social Security..."

False

Not the same old Bush plan

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

"John McCain voted against establishing a national holiday in honor of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr."

True

McCain changed position on MLK Day

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

"McCain opposes a woman's right to choose."

True

McCain opposes abortion

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

"The Children's Defense Fund rated McCain as the worst senator in Congress for children."

True

McCain often absent on children's issues

MoveOn.org

MoveOn.org

"He positions himself as pro environment, but he scored a zero — yes, zero — from the League of Conservation Voters last year."

Half-True

Absences wrecked his rating

Clinton

Hillary Clinton

McCain's "plan for the economy is to extend George Bush’s tax cuts for billionaires and give a $100-billion additional corporate tax cut."

Half-True

That's not the whole plan

Campaign to Defend America

Campaign to Defend America

John McCain and George W. Bush want to spend "a trillion dollars in Iraq over the next 10 years."

Mostly true

Bush and McCain agree on troops in Iraq

Campaign to Defend America

Campaign to Defend America

McCain and Bush are millionaires who are "for tax cuts for millionaires."

Mostly true

Both millionaires; McCain supports Bush's cuts

Campaign to Defend America

Campaign to Defend America

Both McCain and Bush favor tax breaks for oil companies.

False

McCain voted against Bush's energy bill

Campaign to Defend America

Campaign to Defend America

John McCain and George Bush have "absolutely no plan for universal health care."

True

No mandate, no universal care

VoteVets.org

VoteVets.org

"John McCain says it's okay with him if the U.S. spends the next thousand years in Iraq."

True

A fair summary of what he said

Obama

Barack Obama

"We are bogged down in a war that John McCain now suggests might go on for another 100 years."

False

Straight talk, twisted

Sierra Club

Sierra Club

John McCain has "a consistent pattern of ducking important environmental votes."

False

He was campaigning, not ducking

The Democratic National Committee

The Democratic National Committee

The DNC says McCain flip-flopped on whether the Iraq War would be easy.

Half-True

Cherry-picked quotes distort McCain's comments

Dobson

James Dobson

John McCain "said publicly that Hillary Clinton would make a good president."

True

McCain knew it would get him in trouble

Romney

Mitt Romney

John McCain has said the economy is "not his strong suit."

True

McCain said it

Citizens United Political Victory Fund

Citizens United Political Victory Fund

John McCain "voted against the Bush tax cuts, both times."

Mostly true

McCain voted against cuts, now supports them

Citizens United Political Victory Fund

Citizens United Political Victory Fund

"(John McCain) was even mentioned as a running mate with John Kerry."

True

That's the ticket

Romney

Mitt Romney

"Gasoline would rise in price by approximately 50 cents a gallon" if the McCain-Lieberman bill became law.

Barely True

It might whack you ... in 20 or 30 years

Romney

Mitt Romney

"Now, I also support the Bush tax cuts. Sen. McCain voted against them originally. He now believes they should be made permanent. I'm glad he agrees they should be made permanent."

True

McCain switched tax vote

Vietnam Veterans Against John McCain

Vietnam Veterans Against John McCain

Says McCain was a "Hanoi Hilton songbird" who collaborated with the enemy.

Pants on fire!

No evidence McCain was a traitor

Clinton

Hillary Clinton

"You know, Sen. McCain said the other day that we might have troops (in Iraq) for 100 years..."

True

That's no typo, 100 years

Romney

Mitt Romney

"Sen. McCain says it was not a mistake to vote against the Bush tax cuts ... but now says the tax cuts need to be made permanent."

True

Yes, McCain switched

Romney

Mitt Romney

"McCain opposes repeal of the death tax."

Mostly true

McCain wants to keep it on life support

The Democratic National Committee

The Democratic National Committee

"McCain Trying to Have it Both Ways on Iraq"

Barely True

Or maybe Iraq isn't that simple

Romney

Mitt Romney

"Senator McCain voted against the Bush tax cuts. Now he's for them."

True

McCain switched on tax cuts

Romney

Mitt Romney

"(McCain) was opposed to ethanol. Now he's for it."

Mostly true

McCain has come around to favor ethanol

Romney

Mitt Romney

"(McCain) said he was opposed to overturning Roe v. Wade. Now he's for overturning Roe v. Wade."

Half-True

McCain has been pretty consistent on Roe v. Wade

Advertisement
Contribute

No, we don’t want to take your money. But we are more than willing to listen if you know of any facts or story ideas for the Truth-O-Meter. truthometer@politifact.com

PolitiFact.com

PolitiFact is a project of the St. Petersburg Times and Congressional Quarterly to help you find the truth in the presidential campaign. Every day, reporters and researchers from the Times and CQ will analyze the candidates' speeches, TV ads and interviews and determine whether the claims are accurate. >> More

Logos
Sorting out the truth in politics
Candidates

Search PolitiFact via Google

Browse
Feeds

Get PolitiFact:

Knight Batten Award
Advertisement